There are ridges galore on the massive 16th green at Pasatiempo Golf Club in Santa Cruz, Calif. (Jason Scott Deegan/Golf Advisor) A bunker bearing the handiwork of Dr. Alister MacKenzie guards the 14th green at Sharp Park Golf Course in Pacifica, Calif. (Jason Scott Deegan/Golf Advisor) During a renovation project several years ago, the eighth green of the MacKenzie Course at Haggin Oaks was returned to its original location chosen by Dr. Alister MacKenzie. (Jason Scott Deegan/Golf Advisor ) The short par-4 sixth hole at the University of Michigan Golf Course is risk-reward -- with lots of risk. (Mike Bailey/Golf Advisor)

Follow in the footsteps of Augusta National architect Alister MacKenzie at these public golf courses



Even by modern standards, Dr. Alister MacKenzie was a globe-trotting golf architect.

During a career that spanned from 1907 until his death in 1934, MacKenzie -- a British surgeon in his early years who later lived in Santa Cruz, Calif. -- was given credit for designing courses in England, Scotland, Ireland, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Argentina and the United States.

Following in the footsteps of MacKenzie to play his best courses really isn't an option for many golfers. Not only must they traverse the world, they must somehow gain access to his ultra-private courses -- Augusta National in Georgia, Cypress Point in California and Crystal Downs Country Club in Michigan.

Since most of us don't have the cash or the connections to pull this off, I'd recommend the next best route: Sampling MacKenzie's U.S. designs open to the public.

Ireland has two great MacKenzie semiprivate courses I've played -- the Old Course at Lahinch Golf Club and Cork Golf Club -- if you're so inclined to go overseas. MacKenzie courses are considered unique antiques to be treasured.

"MacKenzie is synonymous with the magic and charm of the game," said Bo Links, a Bay Area author and lawyer who has spent countless hours working to save MacKenzie's Sharp Park Golf Course near San Francisco. "His courses, they excite you and exhilarate you. This is the one thought when you are done: 'I want to (play) that again.' There is no architect who had such a complete understanding of the game. His courses are not overly penal, not overly long. They are not easy. They are fun and exciting. It is like a puzzle. You have to figure it out."

Finding the public pieces to the MacKenzie puzzle isn't all that hard. It takes just three trips, one to NoCal, another to the Midwest and a visit to the South during the week of The Masters. Most golfers have these trips planned on their bucket lists anyway.

MacKenzie's public legacy in NoCal

MacKenzie's influence is strongest at the top-100 Pasatiempo Golf Club in Santa Cruz. MacKenzie's former home sits near the sixth green, the ending of a narrow par 5. A statue in the backyard and plaque on the sidewalk mark its location.

His intricate green surrounds and bunkers that sprout fingers in all directions were recently restored by architect Tom Doak, another MacKenzie aficionado who moved to northern Michigan partly because of his love of Crystal Downs. Pasatiempo -- a par 70 of 6,521 yards -- begins by launching off an elevated tee overlooking Monterey Bay. Barrancas crisscross the hillier back nine. The par-4 16th hole ranks as one of golf's scariest holes.

History hasn't been as kind to MacKenzie's two municipal courses in NoCal: Sharp Park in Pacifica and the MacKenzie Course at the Haggin Oaks Golf Complex in Sacramento. Golfers have to look a little harder to find any MacKenzie influences. The 6,382-yard Sharp Park offers more personality from its seaside site than Haggin Oaks, located on the flat land surrounded by highways. Unfortunately, Sharp Park remains in rougher shape, prone to slow greens and flooding. It's still worth the effort to play with unlimited potential for rejuvenation.

The 7,030-yard Haggin Oaks has made a nice comeback condition-wise since Morton Golf took over the maintenance from the city of Sacramento in 2012. MacKenzie's Sports Bar & Grille is home to a trove of memorabilia, articles on past PGA Tour and USGA events held there and even a MacKenzie statue. Interestingly, both courses opened in 1932, the year before Augusta National opened as MacKenzie's lasting legacy.

MacKenzie's Northwood Golf Club, a nine-holer in Monte Rio, seems to charm everybody who discovers it among the towering Redwood trees 80 miles north of San Francisco in wine country. When he visited Northwood, Golf Advisor's Brandon Tucker spent more time looking up at the towering tree canopy than down at his golf ball. When Michigan architect Mike DeVries visited years ago, he marveled at how Northwood grew grass under all that shade. The Russian River borders the 2,893-yard layout on three sides.

Higher learning in the Midwest

Those who want to really go to school on MacKenzie should head to Big Ten country to see the University of Michigan Golf Course in Ann Arbor, Mich., and the Scarlet Course at Ohio State in Columbus. Wouldn't you know it, the Buckeye-Wolverine rivalry even extends to its MacKenzie/Perry Maxwell courses. Which play is better depends entirely upon your loyalty.

The big news is the 6,730-yard U-M course across from The Big House will open to the general public for the first time this season. A limited amount of monthly packages will allow unaffiliated guests to play the U-M course and/or the Radrick Farms Golf Club, a Pete Dye design also owned by U-M, for $110 on weekdays and $140 on weekends. Radrick Farms celebrates its 50th anniversary in 2015. Meanwhile, OSU's Scarlet remains a tougher get, requiring a guest invitation through university employees, students or supporters.

Ohio State legend Jack Nicklaus restored the private Scarlet Course in 2005-06, a task U-M is just starting. DeVries has already expanded several greens at Michigan to bring them back to their original size and shape and hopes to do more extensive restoration work in the near future. Major donations have paved the way for a new clubhouse at U-M to be completed by 2017. The current clubhouse will be demolished this December. Because of a temporary clubhouse, golfers will play the course "out-of-order" in 2016, teeing off the 12th hole and finishing on no. 4.

Don't let the construction or routing changes deter you. The U-M course is, by far, my favorite MacKenzie course to play, even more enjoyable than my rounds at the more highly acclaimed Crystal Downs and Pasatiempo.

Near Augusta National: Southern charm

The Palmetto Golf Club in Aiken, S.C., is the one private course with connections to MacKenzie where anybody can play. The club started opening its doors to the public for the week of The Masters in the early 1980s, according to Head Golf Professional Brooks Blackburn, and sees many of the same faces year after year. Tee times made available in January generally sell out by mid-March, he said. A mix of architects have influenced Palmetto's 6,713-yard layout over the years.

MacKenzie's work is especially interesting given the timing. After finishing up at Augusta in 1932, he was asked to convert the Palmetto sand greens to grass and lengthen the course. In recent years, Rees Jones (1990s) and Doak (2000s) have done restoration work. Gil Hanse now serves as the club's resident architect.

Nicklaus, Doak, Hanse, DeVries, Jones -- they're all vying to be this generation's MacKenzie, the architect whose courses transcend time.

Apr 06, 2015



Join the conversation

Related Links


Jason Scott Deegan

Senior Staff Writer

Jason Scott Deegan has reviewed more than 700 courses and golf destinations for some of the industry's biggest publications. His work has been honored by the Golf Writer's Association of America and the Michigan Press Association. Follow him on Twitter at @WorldGolfer.