RocketJS

Playing as a single, the course had a pretty good layout, fair without any tricked up holes. The staff was helpful and accommodating. The course was in nice shape, greens rolled true. For the price it was a good deal (I played in the PM on twilight rates). Not sure I would pay the going rate for the morning hours. If you can play late, it's a good deal.

On my first trip to San Diego, Torrey Pines South was to be the "star" of the golf trip. Turned out to be a bust. We teed off on time at 12:10 pm and only barely finished at 6:00 pm. Spent virtually the entire day waiting to hit our next shot and we were walking. A group ahead were a hole and a half behind well before the turn. We thought we saw a ranger at one point, however, as soon as we neared him, he drove off without acknowledging us. Never saw another ranger; I realize it is a muni but at the prices out of towners pay, it should at least be a well-managed muni.

Weather-wise it was nice although foggy early. The layout was just OK; a few early holes along the coast were picturesque but the remaining holes (while well manicured) were not memorable.

I feel like I wasted a day of our trip playing this course and was cheated due to the cost. Got the feeling they are a muni coasting on their reputation. Won't happen again.

Booked Maderas on our San Diego trip based on on-line reviews and were blown away by how much we liked this course. It's away from the coast so don't expect seaside (cliffs overlooking the Pacific) vistas. It is tucked into low mountains and ravines with an almost desert feel to it. Great views from the higher points. A nice change of pace from coastal courses.

Expect a wonderful golf experience; beautiful course, great practice facilities, attentive staff. It is a fair test of golf but being paired with players with local knowledge makes a lot of difference. We were lucky and had great playing partners whose advice was very helpful.

It will definitely be on our list of play the next time we are in the San Diego area. A must play course.