Caledonia Golf Club

3.4117647059 3.4 stars from 5 (4)
  • Holes: 18
  • Par: 68
  • Length: 5154 yards
  • Slope: 118
  • Rating: 67.1
  • Layout

  • 9515 Golf Course Rd, Fayetteville, Pennsylvania 17222, Franklin County
  • (717) 352-7271

Year built: 1922
Type: Public
Golf Season: Year round


Carts: Yes
Clubs: Yes


Driving range: No


Walking allowed: Yes
Metal spikes allowed: No
Credit cards accepted: VISA, MasterCard Welcomed

Tees | Layout | Full Scorecard

Tee Par Length Rating Slope
White 68 5154 yards 67.1 118
Red 70 4851 yards 68.9 118

Rating Snapshot

GA Rating Index 3.4 stars from 5
Off-Course Amenities: 2.5 stars from 5
Value: 4.0 stars from 5
Pace of Play: 3.5 stars from 5
Staff Friendliness: 4.1 stars from 5
Course Layout: 3.7 stars from 5
Course Conditions: 3.0 stars from 5
Rating Breakdown 4 Reviews
5 stars:
4 stars:
3 stars:
2 stars:
1 stars:

recommend this course

3 out of 4 reviews



Overall Rating
Type of Golfer

"Much nicer than anticipated"

MGriff70's avatar
Age:  45-54
Skill:  Intermediate
Plays:  Once a week

4 4.0 stars from 5 Played on 08/22/2017
First time playing

Reviewed on

The pro shop is really nice... that's normally your first assessment of a place and your first encounter with the vibe of a course.

That said, the staff was outstanding and friendly and the shop was fully stocked compared to most local clubs.

The tee boxes are hard as rock on some holes-the earlier review is spot on.

And the front nine is more groomed and player friendly than the back nine-true also.

I disagree with the statement claiming the course itself is not taken care of- I'm guessing they went after some rainy days and the mowers hadn't had a chance to cut; but, our outing today had no complaints. Every hole was nicely mown, low fairways and manageable roughs. The greens are great on most holes (a few are in need of some attention-but I'm not complaining).

The "cupped" greens are awesome... there are 2 or three of these; I wish I had known it before hand... I would've attacked them a little more aggressively. I played it safe because I was leary of hitting over them.

Plenty of on course aids too (ball washers, trash cans, port-o-john, etc).

It's a little scary at times, especially for a driver who slices a lot, with a few roads close by... but, live on the edge people!

All-in-all a very pleasureable golfing experience!

Pace of Play: Excellent

Course Layout: Average

Course Conditions: Average

Staff Friendliness: Excellent

Value for the Money: Excellent

Off-Course Amenities: Fair

I recommend this course

"You gotta take care of more than just the greens..."

urbphysics's avatar
Age:  25-34
Skill:  Intermediate
Plays:  Few times a week
Handicap:  20-24

1 1.0 stars from 5 Played on 07/12/2017
First time playing Used cart Hot weather

Reviewed on

The only part of the course that was actually taken care of was the greens. the rest of the course was by far the worst I have played in my life. Layout had promise, with a couple interesting holes (I did particularly like #11) but that did not make up for how poorly taken care of the course was.

Pro shop worker was very nice, but not very knowledgeable. Hole #1 has a small dip into a creek, then comes back up to finally come to the fairway and then doglegs right. I asked him how far it was to carry to get to the fairway and he didn't even know. Shouldn't you know that?

Pace of Play: Poor

Course Layout: Average

Course Conditions: Poor

Staff Friendliness: Fair

Value for the Money: Fair

Off-Course Amenities: Poor

Course Difficulty:  Moderate

I don't recommend this course

"Good Value"

geriw117's avatar
Age:  55-64
Skill:  Intermediate
Plays:  Few times a week
Handicap:  10-14

5 5.0 stars from 5 Played on 08/20/2016
Previously played Used cart Played 18 holes

Reviewed on

Treelined fairways that are narrow present a challenge - you have to place shots in the fairway to score. Many holes require less than driver to properly place the shot. They are letting the rough and 1st cut grow. New owners have spruced the place up and are giving a good value for the money.

Pace of Play: Good

Course Layout: Excellent

Course Conditions: Excellent

Staff Friendliness: Excellent

Value for the Money: Excellent

Off-Course Amenities: Good

Course Difficulty:  Moderate

I recommend this course

"Course Management is Paramount"

PlayItForward280's avatar
Top 250 Contributor
Central PA Advisor
Age:  65+
Gender:  Male
Skill:  Intermediate
Plays:  Once a week
Handicap:  25+

4 4.0 stars from 5 Played on 07/24/2015
First time playing Played with a group Used cart Played 18 holes Excellent weather

Reviewed on

This is an old course. Not much earth was moved; they followed the lay of the land. The front nine is more fun (and easier) than the back nine.

There are unusual features like the "cup" hole on #4. Caledonia has extreme elevation changes like the very steep (going up) #13. It has some very sloped fairways (e.g., #10 and #18). It has forced carries, and it has some landing areas you can't see when you make the shot. Small streams (yes, more than one) cross several fairways, and they are a royal pain, located where well-hit tee shots land or roll out.

Greens are small. They are in good condition, and puts run true.

Some of the fairways are almost hardpan which is why I rated course condition as three stars. Some tee boxes are so hard you just about have to find an old hole to get your tee into the ground.

The staff is very helpful. We were given ice for our drink containers at the pro shop. Course workers temporarily stopped a sprinkler on one green so we could putt out.

Pace of Play: Excellent

Course Conditions: Average

Staff Friendliness: Excellent

Value for the Money: Good

Off-Course Amenities: Good

Course Difficulty:  Somewhat Challenging

I recommend this course

    Marketing Tools for Golf Course Operators

    • Add a Golf Advisor Rating Badge to Your Website. Get Widget
    • Get a feed with the latest reviews for this course Feed