Kiskiack Golf Club

Lay out, greens and fairways are great. Challenging course over all. The staff are incredibly nice. However, The sand traps are just rocks and dirt which really takes away from the experience, especially with how often I end up in traps.

Wonderful conditions but played very slow on back 9

Had some light showers after 3 holes, then they faded away. Course is in great shape! Really enjoy playing here. Greens are pretty quick, fairways are beautiful!

Played there today. Course was in great shape. Fast play, 18 holes in just over 3 hours.

Very forgiving layout and beautiful views. I had a great round and played with 3 locals who helped guide me around the course. Mike probably saved me a couple strokes on his pointers from the black teens. I will play again for sure

Nice course, good layout, not extremely difficult. COVID changes things of course, there was no Marshall - a golfer was blaring hip-hop music from his cart, an older guy in front of us hit 5 balls off the tee on 18 trying to get it over the water (note - he could have hit 100 balls, and he never would have hit it over). Traps weren’t.raked (again COVID), but for a low key round, it was a nice course.

Great challenging course. Played the tips and got every dollars worth.

Only complaint is not about the course but the people that play it. Please have common courtesy to repair divots and ball marks on the greens. Don’t be lazy.

Course is in nice condition but the traps/bunkers are terrible. Looks like they haven’t been tractor raked in a long time. Mostly like dirt with deep ruts and crevices all around.

Totally enjoyed playing golf today. Course is easily walked and in excellent condition. In my opinion dollar for dollar it’s the best course in Williamsburg.

Beautiful isolated setting. Great user friendly design...modest elevation changes. Only issue was traps full of water after heavy rainstorm the night before.

Loved the course, beautiful elevations. Couple guys that play there often pushed us the whole first 9 so that was a little annoying. Only because I rarely get away from my wife and kids for golf and want to enjoy around not hurting my next shot or hurrying on the green so I don’t hold someone else up. But all in all great course. The one other thing that annoyed me is that I left a brand new driver cover in the cart and they can’t seem to find it. Now, I know it’s my fault for not taking care of my property, but it wasn’t like I lost it a month ago. I literally drove back to the course the next day and poof it had vanished.

Had not played this course in bout 6 weeks and was extremely surprised to see the great shape it was in from tee to green.

They just received new carts which were nice to have the ball and club washers on them.

Looking forward to plying this again.

Took the family and had a wonderful time. Thanks!!

The staff are super friendly. It's been wet lately so it's not anyone's fault the course is a little rough. I think it's a great layout and challenges any level of golfer.

It had been a year or two since my last visit to Kiskiack. The GolfNow deal (and GolfPass perks) finally drew me in from Richmond to play.

The course layout is about as good as I remember. Aside from a few holes that feel like a repeat of the ones next to them there's a good mixture here of longer and shorter holes that offer different approach options (spoiler alert: I went for the driver on all of them).

My favorite hole remains the shorter par-4 10th, though I also have an affinity for the par-5 18th and the par-3 17th. Each of them are picturesque and offer a fair and rewarding challenge.

Conditions the day I played were a bit lacking. Yes, it had rained the day before but large puddles in every bunker is a disappointing sight (as is the large-grit sand in them) and it's clear that generally the course struggles to drain well. The greens appear to be recovering from aeration quite well and are generally smooth. I did struggle quite a bit with pace as the downhill putts can get away from you while the uphill putts never seem to have enough juice to get to the hole.

Staff and amenities are both satisfactory. Holes were converted with upside down cups and golfers were encouraged to single-person cart it or walk for everyone's safety. It did appear that ball washers were in use though I simply used a wet towel to wipe off my muddy ball after each hole.

For the price I struggle to find much to complain about here, but perhaps an investment in course drainage (and sand) would warrant a higher greens fee and make the course stand out a bit more.

All things considered, I'd still rather play Colonial Heritage which has nicer conditions and is rarely crowded. But if you are looking for a less daunting challenge, you may prefer it here instead and overall this remains a solid choice for any golfer.